Our world is definitely different. Things have changed. Some of the things that built our world in the past have shifted. One of those things is the perspective on how we think and what faith is. At one time, our world built itself upon the assumption that reason is somehow equal to or superior to faith. What do I mean by that? Simply this: we equated reason as faith.
"Reason" promised to answer all the important questions regarding the universe, truth, and meaning. And if you just reason enough, it would lead you to faith. Or, come let us reason and we'll rationally find complete faith. But what can happen, and what did happen in our world, is that God gets pushed to the edges of our world and faith becomes what you understand not necessarily what you believe. God gets relegated to superstition and reason then becomes God.
Thankfully, this part of our world has shifted. A lot of our culture no longer believes that reason holds all the answers to life's questions. There are other ways to "know" besides singularly through reason. One author said these ways are, "...story, metaphor, feeling, experience, intuition." Faith can develop through a variety of ways. But I wonder, have we (in the present church) seen this culture/world shift? Have we too been guilty at times of promoting reason as equal to or superior to faith?
Scot, what do you think? Have we Christians lived as people of reason (this is different from being "reasonable") to the detriment of being a people of faith?
From Scot:
Paul, good points about “Reason” and Rationalism.
Do you remember last year when you and I went to one of the monthly preachers meetings at the Manchester Church in Connecticut? We shared some information about how things really have changed in our world. In your post above you said that “Reason promised to answer all the important questions regarding the universe, truth, and meaning.” Below is part of the information you and I shared at that meeting in Connecticut. This list is only a sample of what many people think about religion and church and the answers we’ve given in the past. I believe this is an accurate view of what many people in our world believe. I guess reason and rationalism hasn’t fulfilled its promise to answer all our questions after all.
A view of Church from non-church goers:
1. “I can stay home and watch someone preach at me on T.V. . . . But I don't want to.”- Kathy (32), administrative nurse, married mother of one.
2. “The Church is too judgmental. . . and I don't have anything to wear (i.e., socially acceptable).” - Ken and Judy (40's), small business owners.
3. “I'm not religious.” - Amy (29), reads Buddhist writings, dabbles in Judaism and regularly visits physics.
4. “Life is just not as simple as the Church makes it out to be.” - Dave (33), Landscaper, former homosexual now married with children.
5. “Pastors don't live and work in the real world. Their world is the Church. How can they tell me how to live my life? They don't have to struggle with all I have to.” - John (27), elementary school teacher.
6. “I don't fit in. . . . These people are cultural misfits . . . I don't want to become like them” - Jennifer (29), Mother of two, raised in Southern California mega-church.
7. “I don't want to go to church. . . . [The leaders] really don't care about the people. It's all about building a big church with the young and the wealthy.” Ima (82), retired assistant to Pastors , women's speaker...
8. “It's easy for pastors to ask people to put time in at church. . . . They get paid to be there. I have to carve out time from my schedule.” - Ray (29), CDF Fire engineer, father of two.
9. “I believe in Jesus and want to be baptized. But I don't want to change my living situation.” - Roxanne (32), Married mother of two, living with another married man.
10. “I can't trust the leaders. It's like their paid to be nice. They don't know me. They don't want to know me.” - Brian (21), student, raised in church
11. “The church is just to d---- commercial . . . . They're always asking for money and trying to sell me stuff.” - Bob (62), semi- retired electrical engineer.
12. “I don't have to go to church to believe in God. . . I love God, but I hate the church” - Melissa (20), daughter of missionaries.
13. “I am spiritual, believe in God and pray daily though I don't go to church. Church is an angry place- even politically violent at times.” - Paul (52), entrepreneur and son of a mainline pastor.
14. “What's the point? Why should I go to church to sit in an auditorium of strangers to listen to a guy I don't know, tell me how to live a life that I don't even know if he's living?” - Scott (30), civil engineer with no church upbringing.